Lucas Aykroyd: I urge writers to not swallow the notion that you must either adopt AI or get left behind. This only serves the tech oligarchs. It is demonstrably false
Although I am a journalist rather than a university professor, I know how frustrating it can be to confront a rising tide of AI-generated essays from students. In 2017, I founded the Irene Adler Prize, an annual $1,000 US scholarship for women writers with a free-to-enter essay competition. In 2025, I added a no-AI-use rule.
It stings whenever I have to disqualify an essay that is manifestly polluted with glib, hollow phrases spewed by a large language model (LLM), like the ubiquitous “It isn’t just this, it’s that” construction. Inspiring the next generation of journalists and
Source and reference
authors is what I signed up for, not fighting off robots. There is a massive cost for aspiring writers — and our future literary culture — when they ignore Sophocles’ classic principle of “rather fail with honour than succeed by fraud.” And “fraud” is the correct term. When you prompt ChatGPT to write a 1,000-word essay about disease imagery in Hamlet, it is essentially the same as cheating by paying an essay mill to write it for you. (Except that you are too cheap to pay.) If writers do not actively develop initiative, creativity, critical thinking skills, and work ethic in their teens and 20s, they likely never will. Recent studies by the MIT Media Lab and SBS Swiss Business School link LLM use to a decline in cognitive abilities. It is the unsurprising next step down the road after the widespread adoption of smartphones left many users unable to remember phone numbers or...
Read original source- Published
- Jul 15, 2026
- Updated
- Jul 15, 2026
- Source
- Vancouver Sun
- Category
- Technology
- Read time
- 3 min
Key facts
Why this matters locally
This technology story matters locally because it may affect readers, businesses, commuters, families, or public services in British Columbia.
Local impact
BC Post links this item to British Columbia coverage so readers can follow related city updates, weather, traffic, events, and category news in one place.
Timeline
Source and credit
BC Post may summarize, organize, and add local context for reader clarity. Original reporting remains with the listed publisher.